Beliefs

The Yarrow Stalks

the yarrow stalks
The original casting method: fifty stalks, forty-nine used, sorted through three operations per line to birth a hexagram from division and remainder.
Documented

The Great Expansion method

The Xici zhuan (Appended Statements, one of the Ten Wings) preserves the classical yarrow procedure: take fifty stalks, set one aside, divide the forty-nine in two heaps, and count off by fours through three operations to generate each line, yielding old yang, young yang, young yin, or old yin with unequal probabilities. The dayi, Great Expansion, ritual is the oldest documented hexagram-generation algorithm; coin casting is a later simplification with different odds.

Assessment: Documented: the procedure is specified in the Xici zhuan, Han-era text of a Warring States tradition.
Stories

The coin shortcut

Most modern users throw three coins six times, a method popularized for convenience. Critics note it flattens the probability structure: yarrow produces changing yang lines about three times as often as changing yin lines, while three-coin casting equalizes them, quietly editing the oracle's statistical voice.

Assessment: A convenience that changed the odds and nobody noticed.
Interesting claims

The remainder is the message

The method's poetry is mechanical: you do not ask the stalks, you sort them, and meaning precipitates from what remains. Whether one calls it synchronicity or apophenia, the yarrow ritual is a device for surrendering the choice of answer to a process the querent cannot steer.

Assessment: An oracle engineered to be unsteerable.
Sources and further reading
  1. Xici zhuan (Appended Statements), Ten Wings: the Great Expansion (dayi) yarrow procedure
  2. Edward L. Shaughnessy, I Ching: The Classic of Changes (translation), 1996
  3. Richard Wilhelm / Cary F. Baynes, The I Ching or Book of Changes, English ed. 1950, method appendix
Worth asking

If a random sorting of stalks can produce an answer worth obeying, what is the answer actually made of?

Open in the interactive archive
GR8YFILES · competing origin stories, labeled by the strength of their evidence · readers 14+