Faith

The Mylitta Rite

the custom that may never have existed
Herodotus 1.199: every Babylonian woman must once sit in Aphrodite's precinct and accept the first coin thrown into her lap. For twenty-four centuries this was the most quoted proof of sacred prostitution. Modern scholarship's verdict: probably an invention.
Documented

The documented passage

Herodotus describes it fully: women with cord crowns seated in the precinct, roped lanes for the men to pass and choose, the required phrase I invite you in the name of Mylitta, the coin made sacred, the woman forbidden to refuse, and the sting: the tall and fair leave quickly, the plain wait three or four years. Strabo repeats the account with expressed doubt, the Letter of Jeremiah echoes it, and two thousand years of dictionaries and tour books promoted it to Babylonian fact.

Assessment: Fully documented as literature. Documented equally: no Babylonian source, legal, ritual, or economic, mentions any such rite, and the silence is enormous.
Stories

The scandal that built a concept

The passage became the foundation stone of the whole idea of sacred prostitution: from it, generations of scholars inferred temple brothels across the ancient world, reading erotic plaques, priestess titles, and wedding rites as corroboration. The concept grew so load-bearing that entire religions were described as organized around it, on the strength of one Greek paragraph.

Assessment: Stories: the scholarly tradition is real and was real. Its foundation being one travel writer's anecdote was the load-bearing problem.
Interesting claims

The debunk

Stephanie Budin's The Myth of Sacred Prostitution in Antiquity (2008), building on Daniel Arnaud and Julia Assante: sacred prostitution never existed in the ancient Near East; the Mylitta passage reads as an inversion of Greek women's ritual, constructed to barbarize the defeated East, and Strabo's hierodoulos means temple slave, not prostitute. Critics counter that Budin leans heavily on Assante and that the Akkadian dictionaries still list barimtu as prostitute, but the core finding holds: the evidence is literary, late, and foreign, while the local archive is silent.

Assessment: Interesting: the strongest case either way is the silence. The archive files the rite as unproven, the passage as propaganda-shaped, and the episode as the standing example of how one good story outlasts four thousand years of paperwork.
Sources and further reading
  1. Herodotus, Histories 1.199, with the bride auction at 1.196
  2. Strabo, Geography 16.1.20; the Letter of Jeremiah (Baruch 6:43)
  3. Budin, The Myth of Sacred Prostitution in Antiquity (Cambridge, 2008)
  4. Beard and Henderson, With This Body I Thee Worship (Gender and History, 1997)
  5. the counter-critique: reliance on Assante; the Akkadian dictionaries on barimtu (Johnson's Rosetta review, 2008)
Worth asking

Why did history's most documentary civilization leave no document of its most famous alleged custom?

Open in the interactive archive
GR8YFILES · competing origin stories, labeled by the strength of their evidence · readers 14+