Faith

The Edin Parallel

Sumerian edin, the plain
The Sumerian file that Genesis appears to abridge: Sky People, a garden, worker-humans, a flood, told a thousand years earlier.
Documented

The parallels are documented in the tablets

Sumerian and Akkadian texts, excavated and deciphered after the Behistun inscription unlocked cuneiform in the 19th century, describe the Anunnaki under Anu, Enlil, and Enki; the creation of humans as workers in the Atrahasis epic; the watering of the plain of edin; and a flood survivor, Ziusudra or Utnapishtim, loading a boat. These tablets predate the Genesis redaction by a millennium or more. The structural parallels with Genesis 1-9 are standard syllabus in Assyriology.

Assessment: Fully documented: the tablets exist, the translations are published, and the priority of the Mesopotamian versions is not contested. What the parallels mean is the open question.
Stories

The boy on the cliff face

The decipherment story deserves its own card: Henry Rawlinson, an army officer, copied the trilingual Behistun inscription off a cliff in Persia in the 1830s, with local helpers dangling on ropes, and spent years cracking cuneiform from it. Every Anunnaki theory ever aired descends from a man hanging off a mountain copying scratches.

Assessment: Documented: the Rawlinson expedition, the dangling assistants, the decade of decipherment. The folk tier of paleocontact is a story about a rope.
Interesting claims

Genesis is the abridged edition

Wallis's reading: Genesis is the Sumerian archive cut down and re-authored, the committee of Sky People compressed into one God, the workers' revolt erased, the managers' violence attributed to divine justice. The Bible is not the original; it is the remembered version, and the Behistun decipherment accidentally recovered the unredacted file.

Assessment: The dependence of Genesis on Mesopotamian sources is mainstream scholarship in outline. The claim that the originals describe literal off-world managers is the paleocontact step, and it stands or falls with the Anunnaki card two shelves over. The abridgment itself, though, is documented fact.
Sources and further reading
  1. Genesis 2:8-15, the garden in Eden
  2. Sumerian edin, steppe or plain, in the Gilgamesh Enkidu episode and Nippur texts
  3. Samuel Noah Kramer, History Begins at Sumer, 1956
Worth asking

When two archives tell the same creation and the older one names its gods as a working committee, which version is the theology and which is the report?

Open in the interactive archive
GR8YFILES · competing origin stories, labeled by the strength of their evidence · readers 14+