Ideas

The Derivation Program

physics from the dust of minds
the attempt to get Einstein out of a theory of observers
Documented

The stated program

Hoffman's published roadmap, in The Case Against Reality (2019) and the conscious-agent network papers, targets deriving spacetime and quantum probabilities from agent dynamics, with partial results mapping agent structures onto known mathematical objects in physics. It parallels independent work showing spacetime geometry emerging from deeper structures, notably Arkani-Hamed and Trnka's amplituhedron (2013), where locality and unitarity, the pillars of spacetime physics, emerge as consequences rather than axioms.

Assessment: The goal is documented and on the record; the derivation of relativity is not yet done.
Stories

The download-is-loading story

The folk version: science is about to announce that the universe is a mind, any decade now. The announcement has been imminent since Berkeley, 1710.

Assessment: The story mistakes a research program for a result.
Interesting claims

The bootstrap reading

The structural claim worth filing: physics has already been quietly deriving spacetime from elsewhere, from entanglement, from amplitudes, from information, without any consciousness required. Hoffman's bet is that the missing elsewhere is mind. The race is real; both lanes are unfinished.

Assessment: Interesting precisely because the mainstream lane is also weird.
Sources and further reading
  1. Donald D. Hoffman, The Case Against Reality, 2019, the derivation roadmap
  2. N. Arkani-Hamed & J. Trnka, 'The Amplituhedron,' arXiv:1312.2007, 2013, spacetime as emergent
  3. C. Fields, D.D. Hoffman, C. Prakash & R. Prentner, 'Eigenforms, interfaces and holographic encoding,' Constructivist Foundations, 2017
Worth asking

If spacetime can be derived from the structure of observation, was it ever there before anyone looked?

Open in the interactive archive
GR8YFILES · competing origin stories, labeled by the strength of their evidence · readers 14+