Words

Soldier

SOHL-jer
A fighter for a state, from Latin solidus, a gold coin, the one whose pay is solid.
Documented

The solidus man

Latin solidus: solid, firm, and the name of a late Roman gold coin. Soldarius became the man paid in solidi, the professional fighter as opposed to the levied farmer. Old French soldat, English soldier: the mercenary origin is not hidden, it is the word itself.

Assessment: Documented: the coin, the paymaster logic, and the word's path are standard.
Stories

Blood money, itemized

The reading every veteran recognizes: the name admits the transaction. Rome's legions were history's first large standing professional army, and language recorded the innovation honestly, these are the paid ones.

Assessment: Stories: the honesty is real but incidental; no Roman chose the name as confession.
Interesting claims

Solid underneath

The adjective's other children: solid, consolidate, solder (to make solid). The soldier and the solder joint share a promise, to hold firm, and the coin was called solid because it held its value when others debased. Firmness as the family trade, in metal, metalwork, and men.

Assessment: Interesting: the semantic unity of the solid- family is real and oddly complete.
Sources and further reading
  1. Oxford English Dictionary, 'soldier'
  2. Lewis & Short, 'solidus'
  3. Late Roman military pay records, the solidus standard
Worth asking

Is the army a profession that got named after its payroll, or a payroll that grew legs?

Open in the interactive archive
GR8YFILES · competing origin stories, labeled by the strength of their evidence · readers 14+