Science

Pi

the sixteenth Greek letter, pressed into service in 1706
The ratio of a circle's circumference to its diameter, hiding behind a Greek letter. Irrational, transcendental, and at least once nearly legislated into a rounder value.
Documented

The symbol is younger than the steam engine

William Jones, a self-taught Welsh mathematics teacher, introduced pi in his 1706 Synopsis Palmariorum Matheseos, arguing the ratio could never be expressed in numbers and so needed a pure symbol. Euler's adoption made it universal. The ratio itself is ancient: Babylonian and Egyptian approximations, Archimedes' bounds. And the Indiana episode is documented to the vote count: Goodwin's bill to enshrine 3.2 passed the House unanimously in 1897 and died in the Senate after Professor Waldo of Purdue intervened.

Assessment: Jones 1706 and the Indiana bill are both primary-source documented, including the 67-0 tally. The state's near-miss is not legend; it is legislative record.
Stories

The Bible's circle

The story skeptics love: 1 Kings 7:23 describes Solomon's molten sea, ten cubits across and thirty around, implying pi equals 3. Rabbis and apologists have countered for centuries: the rim had thickness, the measurement ran inside or outside, and one gematria reading finds a correction factor, 111 divided by 106, hiding in the spelled versus read forms of the word for line, bringing the text to 3.1415. The ancient text, in this telling, encoded the correction in its own spelling.

Assessment: The verse is documented; the gematria correction is a documented rabbinic argument, genuinely clever and post hoc in equal measure. Both the problem and the rescue are on record, which is what makes it a good story.
Interesting claims

The pyramid knew it first

The claim, since John Taylor's 1859 The Great Pyramid: the monument's perimeter-to-height ratio encodes pi with an accuracy its builders supposedly lacked, so either the Egyptians possessed advanced mathematics the record hides, or someone else taught them. The rebuttal is structural: any construction built with a rolling drum or wheel for measurement inherits pi automatically, whether the builders ever computed it or not. The circle was in the tool, not the theory.

Assessment: The measured ratio is real; the wheel explanation is documented geometry, not speculation. The pyramid may genuinely contain pi, and it means less than the claim wants, which is the archive's favorite kind of result.
Sources and further reading
  1. William Jones, Synopsis Palmariorum Matheseos (1706), the symbol's birth
  2. Indiana House Bill 246 (1897), vote record 67-0, and Professor Waldo's intervention
  3. 1 Kings 7:23, the molten sea, and the rabbinic qere-ketiv correction
  4. John Taylor, The Great Pyramid (1859), and the wheel-measure rebuttal
Worth asking

A Welsh teacher invented the symbol, a state nearly outlawed the truth, and a pyramid theorist found it in stone. How many times can one ratio be discovered?

Open in the interactive archive
GR8YFILES · competing origin stories, labeled by the strength of their evidence · readers 14+