Ideas

Distinction

La Distinction, 1979
Pierre Bourdieu's masterwork: a sociology of taste proving that aesthetic judgment, what you find beautiful, natural, refined, is class position wearing the costume of personal preference.
Documented

The survey

Documented: La Distinction: Critique sociale du jugement (1979) built on Bourdieu's 1963 and 1967-68 surveys of French consumption and preference, music, food, furniture, newspapers, plus ethnography and photographs. Its documented findings: cultural choices correlate with class origin more than with income, and the aesthetic disposition, preferring form over function, abstract art over representation, is the bourgeois marker, while the taste for necessity defines the working class.

Assessment: Documented: the surveys, the correlations, the 1979 text. The book is a data monograph wearing a philosophical title.
Stories

The classifier classified

The book's documented thesis line: taste classifies, and it classifies the classifier, social subjects are classified by their classifications, distinguish themselves by the distinctions they make. Taste is not self-expression but classificatory warfare, and the weapon works because it feels like neither. The Kantian critique of judgment is the target of the title: the aesthetic was never pure.

Assessment: Documented: the sentence and the book's argument structure. The pure gaze is documented as a class privilege.
Interesting claims

The bestseller problem

The reception, documented: Distinction became sociology's most cited modern classic, named by the International Sociological Association in 1998 among the ten most important sociology books of the twentieth century. Its afterlife's irony: a book arguing taste is domination became itself a marker of distinction, assigned in graduate seminars, its ownership now a class signal. Bourdieu, who collected ironies, would have filed this one.

Assessment: Interesting: the citation count is documented. So is the fact that reading it changes nothing about the reader's classification.
Sources and further reading
  1. Pierre Bourdieu, La Distinction: Critique sociale du jugement, Editions de Minuit, 1979 (primary text)
  2. Bourdieu's 1963 and 1967-68 survey data (the documented evidence base)
  3. International Sociological Association, Books of the XXth Century vote, 1998 (the canonization record)
  4. Immanuel Kant, Critique of Judgment, 1790 (the target of the title)
Worth asking

If your taste were really yours, why does it match your tax bracket?

Open in the interactive archive
GR8YFILES · competing origin stories, labeled by the strength of their evidence · readers 14+